These are my four favorite pizza joints in Indianapolis:
1. Cugino’s, 4751 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis, IN, 46226. 317-545-3663. Carry-out or Delivery. No dine in. This is absolutely the best pizza in Marion county. I’d rate it better than Bazbeaux’s, though it’s just not as trendy. I’d say the pizza is a cross between Bazbeaux, Chicago-style, and Papa John’s. The pizza crust is home-made perfect. It doesn’t have that industrial tasteless-ness of most chains. The sauce is exactly the way I like it. It’s flavorful, but doesn’t burn or bite going down. The toppings are cut thick and generous. Perfect crust + perfect sauce + thick/generous toppings = Perfect pizza. I used to order regularly from them when I lived in Lawrence, and NEVER had a bad pizza or any complaint. They’re across the street from Marsh on Franklin Rd, and south a couple of blocks.
2. Saviola’s Italian Cafe, 4709 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46226. 317-546-3020. Dine in or carry-out. Excellent mom-and-pop pizza/Italian place. I had a regular crust pizza and loved it. Very generous toppings. I like the uniqueness of the pizza recipes that you find at these mom-and-pop places. Pizza sauce and spices were very flavorful with NO acidic bite that you can get at some chain stores. And the cheese topping was noticeably good.
Exceptionally clean, including the men’s room.
They do dine-in and carry out. The menu says ask for their full-service catering menu.
Regular menu has:
Pizza, 7″-12″-14″-16″. Toppings: pepperoni, Italian sausage, Italian beef, ham, bacon, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, pineapple, black olives, green olives, jalapeno peppers, anchovies, extra cheese.
And: breadsticks, wings and sauce, salads, hot Italian subs (pizza sub, paninni, Italian beef, meatball, Italian Sausage, chicken Italiano), spaghetti, cheese ravioli, soft drinks, imported canolli, cheese cake, and fresh baked cookies.
Daily specials (call): lasagna, stuffed shells, fettuccini alfredo, manicotti.
Dining area consists of 6 tables-for-four and 2 tables-for-two.
I was the only one eating-in from 5:30pm to 6:15pm, but there was a steady stream of take-out customers. So the locals must have discovered them since they moved here from Carmel.
Their location isn’t the greatest for drive-by traffic. It’s on Shadeland, between 46th Street and where Shadeland crosses over I-465.
But it’s easy to get to if you know where to look. If you’re coming from the North on I-465, just take the Shadeland exit (the one between 56th St and Pendleton Pike). If you’re coming from the South on I-465, get off at Pendleton Pike, go West on PP to Shadeland, then go North on Shadeland. From the West or East, you can get to Saviola’s via 46th St, then go N on Shadeland.
It’s not a fancy/romantic/elegant place to wine and dine your sweety. But it’s a very clean homey neighborhood place with excellent food.
If you’re looking for a cozy mom-and-pop Italian place, with red and white checkered table-clothes, this place is worth going out of your way for.
3. Magoo’s California Pizza, 4919 West 38th St, Indianapolis, IN, 46254. 317-293-4411. Dine in or carry-out. This is another unique mom-and-pop ethno-pizza combination along the lines of Brownsburg’s Adriatic Pizza, but close by on West 38th street, just west of Georgetown Rd. His business model is similar to Eduardo’s “Charlie Biggs Chicken with Filipino-on-the-side,” i.e., cater to American tastes to pay the bills, but also share your own speciality on the side.
In short: Indian/Pakistani Halal-Zabihah* Pizza !
The owner, from either Pakistan or India, wants the restaurant to be known as _American_ cuisine, specifically California style pizza. Their signature pizza crust is crispy on the bottom, and soft and delicate on the top. I loved the crust on the pizza I had, it was not heavy and chewy “industrial dough” like most of the big chains.
The menu includes standard American pizza shop fare, cheese sticks, wings, potato wedges, curley fries, onion rings, garlic bread, green salad, Philly steak sub, New York steak sandwich, cheeseburgers, California style cheese pizzas with your selection of the standard toppings (but no pork products), oven baked chicken, and fried chicken pieces.
However, the attraction for us ethnic food lovers are the Pakistani items, and the Indian style pizza with ginger.
They offer chicken burgers, chappli burgers and chappli kabab, based on Pakistani recipes. Chappli is minced beef with spices.
They also have a “Chicken Tikka Pizza,” and an Indian style vegetarian pizza with _ginger_.
Their other speciality pizza is a Chicken of Beef combo, with Halal-Zabihah* meat of course. (All meat served in the restaurant is Halal-Zabihah.) The Chicken or Beef combo Pizza comes with either a Red Pizza Sauce, or a Creamy Garlic Sauce.
I had the Indian style vegetarian pizza with ginger. They ask you what level of ginger spice you want. I requested “medium”, but that was still enough for the ginger to have a noticeable after-bite, and lingering after-taste. But that’s what I like about ginger. The toppings (mushrooms, olives, green peppers, onions, tomatoes) were cut in small pieces, but were generously applied.
I’m going back to try the chicken burger and the chappli kabab.
But even as a “pizza only” place, it’s worth going there just for the pizza.
They don’t deliver at present, but do have carry out. The dining area is very large, with a large screen TV. They invite you to hold your party there, with free room rental when you order the food from them. Hours are 11am to 10pm.
The dining area was clean and orderly, but without decorations. The men’s room was cleaner than I expected.
* “Halal” means “permitted/allowed” [meat] (sort of “kosher”) to a Muslim, and “zabihah” means it was slaughtered according to Islamic regulations.
4. Harsi’s Subs & Pizza, 3337 Georgetown Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222. 317-290-0025. Dine in, carry-out, and delivery. What Cugino’s is on the NE side, Harsi’s is on the West or NorthWest side. Harsi’s is a LEGEND in the Eagledale neighborhood. MUCH better than ANY of the chain pizza stores. THICK and GENEROUS toppings. None of that thin cut skimpy stuff. I think Harsi’s pizza rivals Bazbeaux’s, it’s just not as “trendy” or “cool”, but
the pizza is what counts! Harsi’s is also a family-owned small business.